X-Men Evolution Wiki
Brotherhood of Mutants
The brotherhood.png
Biographical Information
Name: Brotherhood of Mutants
Members: Mystique (formerly)

Scarlet Witch
Rogue (briefly)
Boom Boom (briefly)
Pyro (future member)

Species: Mutant
Status: Active
Episode Info
First appearance: Middleverse

The Brotherhood of Mutants or Brotherhood of Bayville, is a group of teenage mutant troublemakers, gathered by Mystique on Magneto's orders, primarily as a counterpoint to Charles Xavier's X-Men. They are recurring antagonists.

Early Life

The Brotherhood of Mutants had an evolving role throughout the series. While the X-Men represent the ideal of mutant responsibility, the Brotherhood of Mutants represents the reality, wasting their powers on selfish, small-time interests. They were little more than a plot device during the first season (often an excuse to have the X-Men fight somebody) but from the second season onward, they semi-retired from costumed villainy and were most often seen hanging out in their run-down house, only occasionally committing petty crimes to pay for bills and food.

Despite their on-going contempt for the X-Men, the Brotherhood of Mutants (particularly Avalanche and Toad) were portrayed in a sympathetic light; they were easily manipulated by their elders; such as Magneto, Mystique and even Principal Kelly, but they were not truly evil. The Brotherhood of Mutants has been known to team up with their rivals, often voluntarily such as in "Ascension" when they aid Shadowcat's group of X-Men in defeating Magneto; who was being controlled by Apocalypse and stand side-by-side with their former enemies at the Xavier Institute. The first time they all worked with the X-Men was to stop the Juggernaut. At the end of the series, the Brotherhood of Mutants has a change in morals and become heroes by joining the S.H.I.E.L.D.'s Freedom Force division.

Season 1

By the end of September, Todd Tolansky, Lance Alvers, Fred Dukes will all be living together in a boarding house owned by Mystique. Before Christmas Pietro Maximoff will have also joined the team, by this time a member named Rogue will have joined and left the team. They will have also gotten into arguments, and even all-out fights with fellow students: Scott Summers, Jean Grey, Kurt Wagner, Kitty Pryde, Evan Daniels and now Rogue who joins the team. They will have even found out their school principal, Ms. Darkhome, is not only Kurt's biological mother and Rogue's adoptive mother but secretly a woman named Mystique.

Season 2

A couple weeks into their 2nd year of living together a blonde teenage named Tabatha Smith comes to live with the boys and takes over Mystique's old room, who has abandoned the boys at the point. She proves to be a good thing for the boys, as during the time of her stay there were no fights between The Brotherhood and The X-Men. She also convinces them to all go to the Sadie Hawkins Dance, gives Fred a haircut, and even joins another team for a month called the Bayville Sirens.

Briefly, Lance decided to join the X-Men, more in an attempt to win Kitty over, but he did stick it out for a couple weeks and seems to have been made better for it in the coming years.

However soon after Tabitha has to give up being a Bayville Siren, Mystique comes back and promptly kicked Tabatha out of her room, and the house. Soon after that, she is replaced by another female member named Wanda who happens to be Pietro's younger twin sister.

The Brotherhood defeats the X-Men.

With a little help from a woman named Agatha Harkness, Wanda has a little better control over her powers. Mystique tells The Brotherhood to raid a mall with their powers to bait out the X-Men. Before Wanda's arrival at the mall, Lance sneaks off to try and warn Kitty but fails at trying to convince her to leave her teammates behind. Wanda shows up and defeats the X-Men. Leading to The Brotherhood's first victory against them.

However later the X-Men and The Brotherhood join together to stop Magneto from creating more havoc with his new arrivals. Only to discover that Pietro has betrayed them all, and is working with his father.

Season 3

Season 4

The Future

Future Brotherhood

When Charles Xavier was under Apocalypse's control, he was able to scan the mind of Apocalypse. In The Future, Xavier saw adult versions of the Brotherhood including Pyro becoming members of S.H.I.E.L.D.'s Freedom Force, hinting at a possible redemption.



  1. Middleverse.
  2. 2.0 2.1 Survival of the Fittest. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; name "S1Ep7" defined multiple times with different content
  3. The Cauldron II.
  4. 4.0 4.1 4.2 The Hex Factor.
  5. 5.0 5.1 5.2 Day of Recovery.
  6. Blind Alley.
  7. Dark Horizon I.
  8. The Stuff of Villains.
  9. Uprising.
  10. Ascension I.
  11. Mutant Crush.
  12. Mindbender.